How Do I Find a Trustworthy Roofing Contractor?

When it’s time to repair or replace your roof, finding the right roofing contractor can make all the difference. Your roof protects your entire home, so you want a company that’s skilled, reliable, and honest. Unfortunately, not every contractor fits that description, and hiring the wrong one can lead to poor workmanship, hidden costs, or unfinished jobs.

For homeowners in Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and across Western Pennsylvania, knowing how to identify a trustworthy roofing contractor can save you time, money, and stress. Here’s what to look for before signing any agreement.

1. Check for Proper Licensing and Insurance

The first and most important step in choosing a roofing contractor is verifying that they’re fully licensed and insured. This protects both you and the workers on your property.

A reputable contractor will carry:

• State or local licensing to perform roofing work in Pennsylvania.

• General liability insurance to cover accidental property damage.

• Workers’ compensation insurance protects against on-site injuries.

  
  

If a contractor hesitates to provide proof of insurance or licensing, that’s a red flag. Always ask to see documentation before work begins.

2. Look for Local Experience

Choosing a local roofing company is one of the best ways to ensure reliable service. Local contractors understand Pennsylvania’s unique weather conditions, from heavy snow to strong winds, and know which roofing materials perform best in the region.

A local company like Gerken Roofing also has a reputation to maintain in the community, meaning they’re more likely to stand behind their work and honor warranties.

Plus, if any issues arise after the job is complete, you’ll know exactly where to reach them for service or follow-up inspections.

3. Read Reviews and Ask for References

Before hiring a contractor, check online reviews on Google, Facebook, or the Better Business Bureau. Consistent positive feedback is a good indicator of professionalism and quality workmanship.

If you want more reassurance, ask the contractor for references from recent customers. Speaking directly with past clients can give you an honest idea of what to expect, from communication to cleanliness to timeliness.

A trustworthy roofing contractor will be proud to share their references and completed project examples.

4. Verify Their Warranties

Reliable roofing companies offer both manufacturer warranties (covering roofing materials) and workmanship warranties (covering installation quality).

Manufacturer warranties protect you if the shingles or materials fail prematurely, while workmanship warranties cover any errors during installation.

Ask your contractor for written warranty details, including coverage terms, length, and conditions. Contractors who stand behind their work will always provide clear, written guarantees.

5. Compare More Than Just Price

It’s smart to get multiple quotes, but don’t automatically choose the cheapest one. Low prices can sometimes mean low-quality materials, unlicensed labor, or shortcuts in workmanship.

Instead, compare quotes based on value, including materials, warranties, and overall reputation. A trustworthy contractor will offer a detailed, written estimate outlining all costs, timelines, and project details.

Be cautious of vague or handwritten estimates. Transparency is key to avoiding surprise charges later.

6. Ask About Materials and Installation Methods

A reliable roofing contractor will take the time to explain your material options and recommend the best solution for your home’s design and budget.

For example, Gerken Roofing proudly installs Atlas Shingles, known for their long-lasting performance, strong wind resistance, and protection against algae streaking. Trusted contractors don’t just “sell” roofs; they educate homeowners and help them make informed decisions.

Ask your roofer about:

• The types of shingles or roofing systems they use.

• The benefits of each material type.

• Installation techniques that ensure maximum durability.

  
  

7. Watch for Red Flags

If a contractor pressures you to sign immediately, requests full payment upfront, or lacks a physical business address, proceed with caution.

Other warning signs include:

• Unmarked vehicles or no company logo.

• Unprofessional communication or missed appointments.

• Refusal to provide written estimates or references.

  
  

A trustworthy roofing contractor values transparency, professionalism, and clear communication from start to finish.

8. Choose a Contractor Who Offers Inspections and Maintenance

A roof is a long-term investment, and it deserves ongoing care. Reputable roofing contractors often provide annual inspections, maintenance services, and emergency repairs to keep your roof performing its best year after year.

When a company offers continued support after installation, it’s a sign they care about long-term relationships, not just one-time jobs.

At Gerken Roofing, we pride ourselves on honesty, craftsmanship, and reliability. Our team is dedicated to helping homeowners protect their investment through high-quality installations, inspections, and roof repair services built to last.

Work with a Roofing Contractor You Can Trust

Don’t leave your roof in the wrong hands; choose a contractor who stands by their work and values your home as much as you do. Call Gerken Roofing today at 724-515-5551 or fill out our online form to schedule your free roofing consultation. We proudly serve homeowners in Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and nearby Pennsylvania areas with dependable roof repair, replacement, and maintenance services.