Is Steel Siding Worth It Compared to Vinyl Siding?

Steel siding can be worth it over vinyl if you want a rigid, non-combustible wall that barely moves with the seasons, and you are comfortable with how its warranty handles hail. Alside describes its Satinwood Select steel siding as a non-combustible product with a Class A fire rating and says it was independently tested to withstand winds exceeding 160 mph. Vinyl is built to move instead, and the Vinyl Siding Institute's installation manual is written around that movement.
Alside lists Satinwood Select as 29 gauge Galvalume AZ-50 steel with a Kynar PVDF finish and puts its thermal expansion at less than one-eighth inch over a 12-foot panel, while the Vinyl Siding Institute's manual says vinyl siding can expand and contract half an inch or more over a length of 12 feet 6 inches with normal, year-round changes in temperature. Alside's Satinwood Select warranty, dated June 2026, adds 50 years of hail protection, but for hail the homeowner must go to their homeowners insurance first, and Alside then covers replacement material only after a payment of $200 per incident. The sections below cover what steel siding is made of, how it compares with vinyl on movement, impact and fire, what the warranty covers, which styles exist and how to decide.

What is steel siding made of?
Steel siding is sheet steel roll-formed into lap or vertical panels and finished with a factory-applied coating. Alside builds Satinwood Select from what it calls roll-formed 29 gauge Galvalume AZ-50 steel, and its product page describes each panel as pre-treated galvanized steel sealed with a Kynar PVDF finish.
The coating is where Alside's two steel lines split. Its Satinwood line also uses Galvalume AZ-50 steel but carries a PVC coating, and Alside does not state a gauge for it on the current product page or in its April 2026 catalog. For the Kynar version, Alside says a nylon additive gives the finish a 48 percent improvement in scuff resistance over PVC finishes, which is the manufacturer's own claim.
An older Alside Satinwood brochure from 2019 described the steel as 29 gauge G-90 galvanized, so ask for the current spec sheet on the exact product in your quote.
How much does steel siding move compared with vinyl?
Both materials grow and shrink with temperature, and the amount shapes how each one is installed. Alside says Satinwood Select's low thermal expansion is less than one-eighth inch over a 12-foot panel. The Vinyl Siding Institute puts vinyl's movement at half an inch or more for a length of 12 feet 6 inches. The two figures come from different sources and slightly different panel lengths, but the gap between them is wide.
That movement is written into vinyl's installation rules. The VSI manual calls for at least a quarter inch of clearance at all openings and stops, increased to three-eighths inch when installing below 40 degrees F, and it warns against face-nailing or stapling through siding except in very limited applications. A vinyl wall in Irwin or North Huntingdon faces both summer sun and winter cold, and those clearances give it room to move. Gerken also has a guide on how long vinyl siding lasts in Western PA.
Does steel siding hold up to hail, wind and dents?
Alside makes three weather claims for Satinwood Select. It says the 29 gauge steel is meant for "maximum resistance to hail damage and denting," that the panels were independently tested to withstand winds exceeding 160 mph, and that the siding carries 50 years of hail protection. The product page names no wind test standard, so treat the 160 mph figure as Alside's own claim. Hurricane, tornado and windborne objects also appear in the written warranty's list of causes of damage Alside does not warrant against.
Dent resistant still means it can dent. The written warranty covers hail damage, but it does not mention dents from other impacts, so those fall outside its stated coverage.
Hail claims also run through insurance first. Under the warranty, "the homeowner must first pursue their homeowners' insurance policy for coverage," and Alside's hail protection applies if the insurer denies coverage. Even then, Alside pays for material only, labor stays with the owner, and the owner pays Alside $200 for each incident.
Vinyl is closer on this point than it may seem. Alside's vinyl siding warranty, in the version printed in March 2021, also covers hail with replacement materials only and puts the homeowner's insurance first. For what to look for after a storm on either material, see Gerken's post on spotting wind damage on siding after a storm.
Is steel siding fireproof?
Steel siding is non-combustible, which is a narrower claim than fireproof. The Building America Solution Center, run by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory for the U.S. Department of Energy, describes non-combustible materials as ones that will not ignite, burn or give off flammable vapors when exposed to fire or heat. It lists most metal sidings in that group, along with brick, stone, stucco and fiber cement. Alside rates Satinwood Select Class A and calls steel a non-combustible product.
Vinyl reacts to heat in a different way. FEMA's 2008 Home Builder's Guide to Construction in Wildfire Zones (FEMA P-737) notes that vinyl siding does not burn but can melt at high temperatures, and it lists metal among recommended wall materials. The same FEMA fact sheet also lists metal siding that is susceptible to warping among materials it does not recommend, so non-combustible does not mean unaffected by heat.
What does Alside's steel siding warranty cover?
Alside calls Satinwood Select's coverage a lifetime limited warranty. The written warranty dated June 2026 breaks it down this way:
Who is covered: the original property owner, for as long as they are living and own the home.
Defects: manufacturing defects that cause cracking, chipping, flaking, peeling or splitting, or that cause rust to perforate or deteriorate the steel.
Color and chalk: color change of no more than Delta E 5 Hunter units, and chalking within set limits, for 35 years from installation.
First three years: Alside, at its option, repairs, refinishes or replaces defective siding at no cost to the owner.
After three years: Alside covers material and labor once the owner pays $100 for each incident.
Hail: 50 years, with the insurance-first and material-only terms described above.
Transfer: once, to the next owner, with coverage prorated by the year of the claim.
Proration after a sale is the detail to read twice. Alside's product page calls the warranty non-prorated, but the written warranty prorates claims after a transfer: Alside pays 100 percent in years 1 to 5, then 10 points less each year, down to 20 percent in year 13 and 10 percent from year 14 on.
The warranty also lists exclusions, including improper installation, salt spray or fumes, lap abrasion, vandalism and failure to keep the siding free of built-up dirt, staining or mildew. Ask the installer for the printed warranty before signing so you know which product and terms apply.
Which steel siding styles and colors are available?
Alside's April 2026 catalog lists four Satinwood Select profiles: Double 4 inch and Double 5 inch clapboard, a single 8 inch clapboard and a 12 inch vertical board and batten. The horizontal panels are 12 feet 6 inches long with a roughsawn texture, the board and batten panels are 10 feet long with a woodgrain texture, and the catalog shows 12 colors. Alside's product page adds a half-inch panel projection.
The PVC-coated Satinwood line has a similar set of profiles plus a Double 5 inch Dutch lap, all in woodgrain textures and 8 colors. Alside's catalog also warns that color availability varies by product and market, so confirm the color with your installer early. If you are still deciding on a palette, this guide to choosing a siding color can help.
How do you decide between steel and vinyl siding?
Steel's case rests on non-combustible panels, Alside's low movement figure and long color and hail coverage. Its trade-offs are hail claims that go through insurance first and pay for material only, no stated coverage for other dents and coverage that prorates after a sale. Vinyl moves far more, so its results depend on an installer who follows the VSI manual's clearance and fastening rules.
For price, see Gerken's breakdown of what new siding costs in 2026. If fiber cement is also on your list, compare vinyl vs fiber cement siding. Before work starts, ask your township or borough code office whether your project needs a permit.
FAQ
Does steel siding rust?
It can. Alside's Satinwood Select warranty covers manufacturing defects that lead to perforation or deterioration of the steel from rust, but it excludes damage from fumes, vapors or salt spray applied to the siding or present in the air.
Does steel siding fade?
Some, within limits. Alside's steel warranty caps color change at Delta E 5 Hunter units and limits chalking to an ASTM D4214 rating of 8 for colored siding and 6 for white, both for 35 years from installation.
Does steel siding dent?
Yes, it can. Alside markets the 29 gauge steel for dent resistance, yet its warranty addresses hail only and is silent on other dents.
Can steel siding look like wood?
Yes. Alside's catalog lists a roughsawn texture on Satinwood Select's horizontal panels and a woodgrain texture on its board and batten, and the PVC-coated Satinwood line uses woodgrain textures throughout.
What gauge is steel siding?
Alside lists Satinwood Select as 29 gauge. Its current product page and April 2026 catalog do not give a gauge for the PVC-coated Satinwood line, so ask for the spec sheet on whatever product you are quoted.
Do you need a permit to install steel siding in Westmoreland County?
It depends on your municipality. Under 34 Pa. Code 403.1(b)(10), the Uniform Construction Code does not apply to installing aluminum or vinyl siding on an existing home, except as local ordinances may require, and steel siding is not named in that item. Ask the township or borough code office in Irwin, North Huntingdon or wherever you live before work starts.
Steel and Vinyl Siding from Gerken Roofing
Gerken Roofing lists steel siding on its siding page alongside vinyl siding, insulated vinyl siding and Alside Composite Cladding, and the locally owned, family run business works from 414 Main Street in Irwin. The page describes its steel option as galvanized steel fused with a top coat of PVC or PVDF (Kynar), and as a non-combustible product meeting even the most stringent building codes. Homeowners weighing steel against vinyl can Call The Pickle for a free, no-obligation quote.
Visit Gerken Roofing or call 724-515-5551 today. Contact us for more information.





Comments