How Do Premium Shingles Compare to Basic Ones?

If you’re planning a roof replacement, one of the first decisions you’ll face is what type of shingles to use. Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in Pennsylvania, but not all shingles are the same. You’ll often hear roofing contractors refer to “basic” and “premium” shingles, but what’s the difference, and is it worth upgrading?

For homeowners in Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and nearby areas, understanding how premium shingles compare to basic ones can help you make the right choice for your home, budget, and long-term protection.

What Are Basic Shingles?

Basic shingles, also known as 3-tab shingles, are the most affordable type of asphalt roofing material. They get their name from their design; each shingle strip is divided into three tabs, giving the appearance of individual tiles once installed.

These shingles are lightweight and simple to install, making them a cost-effective choice for many homes. However, they typically offer less durability and shorter lifespans than higher-grade options.

Average lifespan: Around 15–20 years with proper maintenance. 

Best for: Homeowners on a tight budget, rental properties, or short-term ownership.

Advantages of Basic Shingles

• Lower upfront cost: They’re the most budget-friendly roofing option.

• Easy installation: Fewer materials and less labor make for quick installation.

• Traditional look: They provide a simple, clean aesthetic that fits many older homes.

  
  

Disadvantages of Basic Shingles

• Shorter lifespan: They wear down faster under harsh weather.

• Less resistance: More likely to crack, curl, or blow off in strong winds.

• Limited curb appeal: Fewer color and style options compared to premium shingles.

  
  

While basic shingles get the job done, they’re best for homeowners prioritizing affordability over long-term performance.

What Are Premium Shingles?

Premium shingles, also known as architectural or designer shingles, are a step up in both quality and appearance. They’re thicker, heavier, and designed with multiple layers for added durability and texture.

Unlike basic 3-tab shingles, premium shingles mimic the appearance of high-end materials like cedar shakes or slate, giving your roof depth and dimension while boosting curb appeal.

Average lifespan: 30–50 years depending on material and installation.

Best for: Long-term homeowners, those seeking higher resale value, and homes exposed to severe weather.

Advantages of Premium Shingles

• Superior durability: Multi-layer construction provides better protection against wind, hail, and heavy rain.

• Longer lifespan: Many premium shingles come with lifetime limited warranties.

• Enhanced appearance: Textured designs add dimension and sophistication to your home.

• Improved energy efficiency: Certain premium shingles reflect more sunlight, helping reduce cooling costs.

• Stronger warranties: Manufacturers often offer extended protection on premium products.

  
  

Disadvantages of Premium Shingles

• Higher cost: Upfront installation costs are higher due to material quality and labor.

• Added weight: Heavier shingles may require extra structural support in older homes.

• Longer installation time: Because they’re layered and textured, they take more time to install properly.

• While premium shingles cost more upfront, they provide better long-term value through fewer repairs, longer lifespan, and improved energy efficiency.

  
  

Why More Pennsylvania Homeowners Choose Premium Shingles

Western Pennsylvania’s mix of rain, wind, snow, and temperature swings makes durability an important factor when choosing roofing materials. Premium shingles, like those from Atlas Roofing, are engineered to withstand these challenges with advanced protection technology such as:

• Scotchgard™ Protector: Prevents unsightly algae streaks and discoloration.

• High wind resistance: Keeps shingles secure even during storms.

• Impact-resistant designs: Reduce damage from hail and debris.

  
  

At Gerken Roofing, we frequently recommend premium shingles for long-term homeowners because they provide the best combination of beauty, performance, and protection, especially in Pennsylvania’s unpredictable climate.

Are Premium Shingles Worth the Investment?

If you plan to live in your home for many years or want to increase its resale value, premium shingles are absolutely worth the investment. They not only reduce the need for frequent repairs but also give your home a higher-end look that stands out in the neighborhood.

On the other hand, if you’re selling soon or replacing the roof on a smaller property, basic shingles may be a more practical choice.

Upgrade Your Roof with Lasting Quality and Style

Whether you’re choosing basic or premium shingles, Gerken Roofing can help you find the perfect balance of cost, appearance, and performance. Call 724-515-5551 or fill out our online form to schedule your free roofing consultation. We proudly serve homeowners in Pittsburgh, Greensburg, and nearby Pennsylvania communities with trusted roof installation and replacement services.